Skip to main content
Protocol Wealth

·3 min read

Technology and the hard reset: scaffolding or circumvention

Every new tool raises the same question: does it extend our judgment or stand in for it?

By Nick Rygiel, CFP® · Co-Founder and Chief Technology Officer

Technology and the hard reset: scaffolding or circumvention

Socrates distrusted writing. In Plato's Phaedrus he argues that it will breed forgetfulness and give people the appearance of wisdom without the substance.1 Socrates wrote nothing. We know what he thought mainly because Plato wrote it down.

Before writing, much of what a master knew could die with the master unless an apprentice had stood beside him for years. Writing weakened that hard reset. It did not replace thinking. It let thinking accumulate.

That is the question to ask of every tool, AI included. Does it extend what a person can do, or does it stand in for the person?

Two ways to use a tool

Circumvention: outsourcing judgmentScaffolding: extending reach
A calculator used in place of knowing roughly what the answer should beWriting things down so ideas outlive the person who had them
Generated text standing in for thoughtChecklists and navigation aids that cover known blind spots
Software fixes shipped without review, breaking systems that workedA first draft produced quickly, then judged by someone who knows the subject

The U.S. Naval Academy stopped teaching celestial navigation in the late 1990s, when computers and GPS had taken over the work. In 2015 the Academy brought back a short course, out of concern about what happens if GPS fails or is attacked.2

GPS is scaffolding for a navigator who understands navigation. It is circumvention for one who does not. Same tool. Different person holding it.

What happened the last time analysis got cheap

The electronic spreadsheet arrived in 1979. Work that took a clerk a day took seconds. It did not end accounting. Many bookkeepers and accounting clerks were replaced, and the number of accountants grew, as their work moved from adding up numbers to thinking about the business.3

There is early evidence that businesses are using more AI as it gets cheaper, though four weeks of one company's data is not a trend. Among companies that track their AI usage through the payments firm Ramp, usage measured in tokens rose 27% in four weeks this autumn.4

This month also showed the other column. Derek Thompson described companies rushing out software fixes for newly discovered flaws and breaking their own systems in the process.5 Speed without review is circumvention, whoever or whatever writes the fix.

For a business owner

Use AI to design the work. Keep people and fixed rules running it.

  • At design time, use it freely. Have it organize your procedures, find where two documents contradict each other, and produce the tenth draft that nobody has the energy for.
  • At run time, keep decisions with people and fixed rules. Hiring, spending, client relationships and changes to software should pass through checks that behave the same way every time, and through a person who answers for the result.
  • Learn it now, while it is simple. The tools are at an early stage. The habits you build with them matter more than any trick for phrasing a request.

The account-security version of this is in Steel doors, weak latches, and the market version is in Among the widest in 40 years.


Protocol Wealth, LLC is an SEC-registered investment adviser. Registration does not imply a particular level of skill or training. This article is for information only and is not investment, legal or tax advice. Companies are named to report public information, not to recommend their products or securities.


  1. Plato, Phaedrus, 274c–277a; "Socrates," Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/socrates/ ↩
  2. Military Times, "Naval Academy reinstates celestial navigation," November 1, 2015, https://www.militarytimes.com/news/your-military/2015/11/01/naval-academy-reinstates-celestial-navigation/ ↩
  3. Jacob Goldstein, "How The Electronic Spreadsheet Revolutionized Business," NPR, February 27, 2015, https://www.wfae.org/2015-02-27/how-the-electronic-spreadsheet-revolutionized-business; NPR Planet Money, "Episode 606: Spreadsheets!", February 25, 2015, https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2015/02/25/389027988/episode-606-spreadsheets ↩
  4. Ramp AI Index: token volume up 27.2% between the week ending October 18 and the week ending November 15, 2026, among companies using Ramp's token-spend product, https://ramp.com/data/ai-index ↩
  5. Derek Thompson, "Why Everything Is Suddenly Breaking All at Once," November 19, 2026, https://www.derekthompson.org/p/why-everything-is-suddenly-breaking ↩

Protocol Wealth LLC is an SEC-registered investment adviser (CRD #335298). Content is educational; not investment advice. Full disclosures at/disclosures.